2013 · Q37
Which one of the following describes best the concept of Nirvana in Buddhism?
- (a)The extinction of the flame of desire
- (b)The complete annihilation of self
- (c)A state of bliss and rest
- (d)A mental stage beyond all comprehension
Show answer and explanationHide answer and explanation
Nirvana translates as blowing out or extinguishing, and what is extinguished are the three fires of the Buddhist analysis: raga or craving, dvesha or aversion, and moha or delusion. This follows directly from the Second and Third Noble Truths, which locate the origin of suffering in tanha, craving, and identify liberation with its cessation.
- Option (a) states this in the metaphor the tradition itself uses and is the official answer.
- Option (b) is incorrect and is the most instructive wrong answer, since it asserts annihilation of a self whose existence Buddhism denies at the outset. The doctrine of anatta holds that there is no permanent substantial self to annihilate, only the five aggregates in flux, so nirvana cannot be the destruction of a self; the Buddha treated both eternalism and annihilationism as extremes to be avoided.
- Option (c) is incorrect because it describes nirvana as a positive hedonic state, which assimilates it to the heavens of the cosmology, themselves impermanent and within samsara; the tradition describes it as the cessation of suffering rather than as pleasure.
- Option (d) is incorrect because although nirvana is held to be beyond conceptual description, the question asks what best describes the concept, and an assertion that it cannot be described is an evasion rather than a description. The elimination route is anatta, which defeats option (b) outright and is the fact the question is really testing.
Moderate · Static · Art and Culture · Religion, Philosophy and Devotional Traditions